(I wasn't really sure if this might fit into "Development", so I put it here, maybe a mod will move it, if it's a dev topic )
Anyways, here we go, I DUALBOOTED two different, independant ROMs on the S2
Video of dualboot in action: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9-V_6Ua_D0
** THIS IS NOT (YET) COMPATIBLE **
** WITH ICS (ANDROID 4.0.x) ROMS! **
-- this goes for custom ROMs as well as stock ROMs --
Icey Sammich compatibility will be added once Sammy released their ICS kernel sources.
!!! There now is an app for more convinient and easy setup of the dualboot !!!
(04.11.2011) DualBoot setup app v2.00: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=19049047&postcount=94
(12.12.2011) App has been updated to 2.51, lot's of good new stuff! >> Free Version -- Donate Version <<
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
First off:
This is only a little experiment I did like "c'mon, has to be possible" - this is NOT (at least yet) tweaked for usability and anything the like, just a humble experiment.
That said, don't flame me if things are rather complexicated to do this ATM.
Maybe I'll come up with a more userfriendly way of setting this up, maybe someone else does, maybe no one does.
Also now that I found a base on what to do, there might be different ways (more easy ones maybe) to set this up, I'll keep toying around with it.
But let's cut to the chase, shall we
So, how was this set up? I'll give a brief rundown of what I did:
I edited a few .rc files in the initramfs of the kernel to make it actually perform a full boot when recovery mode was triggered and to fire up recovery mode when in battery-charging mode.
I also edited a few mounts in the boot .rc for the 2nd OS (in "recovery" mode) to use different partitions for /system and /data, so that we'd end up with really independant installs.
What partitions did I missuse for that:
partition 12 (mostly unused, only when installing a stock ROM AFAIK) for /system - that's a neat choice IMO as p12 is 512MB in size, just as p9 where /system usually sits on
partition 7 (which is usually /cache) for /data
gives us only 100MB of user data space, but for now that's OK, as said, it's only an experiment on how such a thing could be done.
with the original partition for /cache "gone", I mounted a tmpfs for it.
So the OS still has a usable /cache
Then I set up the two OSes:
(dualboot kernel not yet flashed)
Launchprep part 1:
I made a CWM backup of my normal installation I was running (stock XXKG6 at the time).
I installed DevNull-Test AOSP as to it's instructions
Some su'ed voodoo via a terminal while having the 2nd OS (the DevNull AOSP one, in this case) installed - best done in recovery mode via ADB:
rm -Rf /cache/*
cp -Rp /data/* /cache/
dd if=/dev/block/mmcblk0p9 of=/dev/block/mmcblk0p12 bs=4096
That did "set up" the 2nd OS to where it's supposed to go.
Launchprep part 2:
Then, "advanced restore" of the backup made a few minutes earlier:
- boot
- system
- data
Reboot
At this point OS #1 is running again and OS #2 is sitting in hiding, prepared to roll - so, let's roll:
Flashed the modified "dualboot kernel" (via an App or Odin or magic, doesn't matter).
---> DONE <---
reached the point to where everything works as shown in the video.
As said above already, yes it needs some manual work to set it up, yes there's a lot of things that might not work, yes there are other/better ways to set it up.
It's only a humble experiment - lot's of space for improvement.
Maybe you like it - for those who do, I wanted to share this
Attached to this post you find the modified kernel I used, it's based on my v1.20 custom kernel (see sig) but with the above mentioned changes.
I've seen the video m8, this is totally different approach, ur giving this device a new dimension. love u "in a straight way" hahaa
there currently an app called Bootmanager which also handle up to quadruple booting. But sadly currently only support HTC phones.
http://www.appbrain.com/app/bootmanager/com.drx2.bootmanager
well, one can hope!
Thanks OP this is an awesome concept! Very happy to see you posted it with a video! and nice boot animation!
sunwee said:
there currently an app called Bootmanager which also handle up to quadruple booting. But sadly currently only support HTC phones.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, that's the thing.... that app is HTC only.... but we have Samsung S-II and want dualboot as well.
I'm already brainstorming on how to enhance the actual usability of this, i.e. flashing a 2nd OS directely to it's place instead of first installing it to the main system partition. But there is problems when /data is not mounted to the original partition, at least stock doesn't like it on initial boot.... well, well....
That is great. Going to use this for sure. This should be in development for sure.
Congratulations already.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk
This is impressive bro sure will use it
but i want to ask one thing
SD card needed for this or not ?
That would be really cool (and definitely should goes to original development). Does it work with CM7/MIUI + custom rom?
vikas776 said:
SD card needed for this or not ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, so far this completely works with all internal storage.
But I have a few ideas I have yet to try to get mounted from other places - like images in /sdcard for example (I *so* hope that'll work.... )
Hi
Does this kernel include any of the Hellcat kernel tweaks or are they work in progress.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk
Tricky103 said:
Does this kernel include any of the Hellcat kernel tweaks or are they work in progress.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I made this build based on my v1.20 custom kernel, so it has everthing that one has - plus the touchfix already
exactly what i was hoping for.
great job - pls continue your work
Hi i tried this with instanity rom last night. When I use the three buttons to boot it just sits there not booting. My guess is the kernel is not compatible. Unless I made a mistake somewhere.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk
Hm, yah, might be that the kernel isn't fully compatible with that ROM, what kernel does the ROM usually use?
Did you boot it up fully at least once before copying /data to /cache ?
Yes I did fully boot up. But his kernel didn't have advanced activated in recovery so I flashed your kernel and moved the cache okay. But it said /data not found when I ran the 2nd command line.
I will flash aosp later. I like that rom.
I am not sure what kernel nitr8 uses. I think it is his own, Insane.tar would you like it to see if they can work together.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk
Tricky103 said:
But it said /data not found when I ran the 2nd command line.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hm, yeah, that sounds like something didn't work.... make sure you run those commands as root, i.e. "su" as very first command (I'll add that to the first post).
Give me a direct link to the ROM and I'll try it.
Make take a few days though as I'm away from my computer a lot because of work the next two days, but I'll try once time permits.
Well yeah, and this still is in highly experimental stage, if I (or someone else) should ever get this to more stable and reliable state, I'll make an easy to use installer/setup tool
But I got a few other ideas on setting it up I have to try first....
http://goo.gl/2uZCh
This is the complete rom. Only 47mb. I thought you would like the whole rom
Tricky103 said:
Hi
Does this kernel include any of the Hellcat kernel tweaks or are they work in progress.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
May be someday WINDOWS Mo 7 and Android on our sweet beast
Hi
I tried again with Aosp Dev-null. I still get this error "cp: can't stat '/data/*': No such file or directory "
after running this command line " cp -Rp /data/* /cache/ "
Any Ideas ?
It still doesn't boot if I press 3 button it brings up the boot logo and then black screens until it boots to the 1st partition.
Thanks for the link, will download and try as soon as time permits.
Also, try this command sequence, I got an idea what the issue maybe might be, give it a shot:
Code:
su
rm -Rf /cache/*
busybox cp -Rp /data/* /cache/
dd if=/dev/block/mmcblk0p9 of=/dev/block/mmcblk0p12 bs=4096
(use "busybox cp" instead of plain "cp", maybe it helps)
And some update on my ongoing thoughts for those interested:
- got an idea on how to make a more easy to use App for prepping and setting up the dualboot environment
- managed to do a neat thing I didn't really think it would work: issued a "mount" command and the OS thought it was mounting a partition of the internal flash (/dev/block/mmcblk0p12 in this test, but was testing for later on actually doing it with p9 - you might see where I'm headed here ) but instead of the partition it actually mounted from an .img file! (loopback)
i.e. "mount /dev/block/mmcblk0p12 /somedir" actually mounted "/somepath/someimage.img" to "/somedir" instead of the partition from /dev/block/... (you just gotta love Linux and it's flexible way of handling things....)
NOW, imagine /dev/block/mmcblk0p9 (the partition carrying the system) and p10 (data) being (kinda) transparently mounted from an IMAGE FILE
I "only" have to find a way to sneak this in before init starts mounting stuff.
If there's a way to do THAT.... unlimited multiboot from OS images, anyone?
(so far this is kinda dreaming, but would be cool to get it working )
Related
I want to try developing for the DSTL1 / N21
There are quite a few interesting things we can do...
Success has been been seen by xda-devs such as JesusFreke, Amon_RA, Haykuro, and Cyanogen (yes there others) in the field of Android ROMs. The ground work is there, porting and developing can commence.
Why do this?
Current ROM 1.5 - has many problems...
Unofficial ROM 1.6 - is a GREAT improvement, but makes one hungry for something better...
It would be awesome to have some success in this field. I know this device is capable of so much more, but I believe the implementation of the system is the issue. This is not the phone developers fault, as they have their own company agenda, but we could improve our own performance and satisfaction .
For example, my device (1.6 rooted) lags with having only ~50% CPU utilization and ~50MB RAM free...
Overclocking (i mean forcing full CPU capacity - 624Mhz) the CPU has barely helped and only aided battery drain...
Relevant comparison of G1 vs DSTL1 (N21) are
RAM - G1: 192MB vs DSTL1: 128MB
CPU - G1: 528Mhz vs DSTL1: 624Mhz
These specification comparisons say that G1 can run a better ROM than DSTL1? I don't think so. DSTL1 only loses in RAM, which can be made up for using swap!
Devs had success with techniques using: App2SD, swap, ext3, and BFS (faster file system). I believe we could do something impressive here! There are pros and cons to this.
Developers and Testers would be needed. A team of 5 developers and a few testers should be able to get us on the right track. We would definitely need Linux experience, or the desire and ability to soak up all the info on Google
A Linux kernel is a must for this phone, we would have to compile our own... It would be nice to preserve DUAL SIM, but in reality we might have to give up this luxury, as it is proprietary code, unless a new ROM is made backwards compatible (which is possible).
Cyanogen's Github is available for knowledge osmosis http://github.com/cyanogen
A DSTL1 Recovery by Amon_RA (based on Cyanogen's Recovery) is already in Beta...
Cool things are possible. Could I find some developers willing to donate their free time?
Please limit responses to dev talk.
reserved for later
crzyruski,
Believe it or not the very luxury you talk about giving up(dual sim) is the reason why may of us bother to buy these phones(DSTL1\N21) in the first place. Other wise we might as well go with a mainstream phone such as hero etc.
chrismotto said:
crzyruski,
Believe it or not the very luxury you talk about giving up(dual sim) is the reason why may of us bother to buy these phones(DSTL1\N21) in the first place. Other wise we might as well go with a mainstream phone such as hero etc.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Its a possibility that I'm not going to ignore, so I stated it.
The point is that the current OS is lacking. Initially we would want to port and learn from porting of the quality ROMs available now. Those obviously don't support dual-SIM.
Progress needs to start from somewhere. When someone releases a new port or ROM not all pieces work... look at the Eclair (2.0) port, half the features don't work!
If enough heads came together we could probably retain dual-SIM, common this is linux and I've seen the most amazing development come to realization. I just need the teamwork because it might take me a whole year in my spare time...
Having a kernel working
Hi,
the most important IMHO is having a kernel working, built from sources.
Obviously, some closed source drivers must be rewritten, notably the NXP5209 (the GSM modem), if we want the device to be useful (i.e. if we want to make phone call).
My first attempt of booting with a custom kernel was unsucessfull (black screen), which brings to the second point: the lack of some sort of console for kernel debuging.
Any idea regarding the NXP? Anyone is aware of some opensource driver or specs?
Any idea also regarding kernel debugging in the N21/DSTL1?
sfabris
@sfabris
I will try to find info for the questions you have.
My initial work will be to make an emulator so we can test on PC and not our devices (because we need them functional for every day life )
Have you checked out how other modders have done kernel modifications?
Namely JF and Cyanogen?
I can't begin to comprehend so I'm glad you took the initiative with this.
Lets make some progress
sfabris said:
Obviously, some closed source drivers must be rewritten, notably the NXP5209 (the GSM modem), if we want the device to be useful (i.e. if we want to make phone call).
Any idea regarding the NXP? Anyone is aware of some opensource driver or specs?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Maybe we have it all wrong???? Maybe its PNX?
PDA DB reports DSTL1 as having Nexperia PNX5209 (ARM946) Phone Controller.
http://pdadb.net/index.php?m=specs&id=1714&view=1&c=general_mobile_dstl1
A similar Android with this phone controller is WayteQ X-Phone (TechFaith Lancer)
http://pdadb.net/index.php?m=specs&id=1801&view=1&c=wayteq_x-phone_android_techfaith_lancer
crzyruski said:
@sfabris
Have you checked out how other modders have done kernel modifications?
Namely JF and Cyanogen?
I can't begin to comprehend so I'm glad you took the initiative with this.
Lets make some progress
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As I'm forced to HTC G1 until I'll wait the replacement for my N21 I'll go in detail on the kernel boot process on other hardware.
A fast way to test kernel in our every day device is kexec which should work also on ARM.
sfabris said:
A fast way to test kernel in our every day device is kexec which should work also on ARM.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As far as I understand, kexec is a program that can run a new kernel on the fly...
So I could try a new kernel right from my device without reflashing?
have you tried this? Or is this still theory?
crzyruski said:
As far as I understand, kexec is a program that can run a new kernel on the fly...
So I could try a new kernel right from my device without reflashing?
have you tried this? Or is this still theory?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've tried it on x86, never on arm.
Support is there also for arm, but this not imply that also the Marvell PXA is supported.
It's basically the same way of booting Android from WM via haret.
Fastest way to boot your new kernel or to crash your machine
I have created an emulator.
FYI, LCD density should be 120.
Edit: Technically the density is 133...
files prevent recovery-RA-DSTL1-v1.2.3 from loading
I have been wrestling with the beta recovery-RA-DSTL1-v1.2.3
Amon_RA retrofitted his own recovery image to work for the DSTL1 (N21)...
IT HAS AWESOME POTENTIAL.
Currently ADB RECOVERY SHELL + ROOT is the only thing that is functional.
But I haven't been able to get in touch with him to continue work on it.
The following files prevent me from booting into RA's Recovery, so I remove them:
- e2fsck
- mke2fs
- parted
- tune2fs
Once I am in ADB RECOVERY SHELL I can push them back on and do what I need to do.
Unfortunately the changes are persistent so if I were to reboot and try Recovery Mode again, it won't load
What is so special about those four programs that prevent my recovery from loading?????
is there any ways to update the firmware of N21
hi,
i'm just buy a sciphone n21 (actually is already in our office for 2 weeks but find it now:-( )
and i've to face myself in a situation that i can't use this phone:-( since i buy this phone because:
- i assume that google apps auto sync contact and calendars. unfortunately this phone has not google apps by default.
- and has dual sim support.
so my question: is there any way to upgrade it to a firmware which support is?
can i do anything to use my phone?
thanks in advance.
regards.
crzyruski said:
I have been wrestling with the beta recovery-RA-DSTL1-v1.2.3
Amon_RA retrofitted his own recovery image to work for the DSTL1 (N21)...
IT HAS AWESOME POTENTIAL.
Currently ADB RECOVERY SHELL + ROOT is the only thing that is functional.
But I haven't been able to get in touch with him to continue work on it.
The following files prevent me from booting into RA's Recovery, so I remove them:
- e2fsck
- mke2fs
- parted
- tune2fs
Once I am in ADB RECOVERY SHELL I can push them back on and do what I need to do.
Unfortunately the changes are persistent so if I were to reboot and try Recovery Mode again, it won't load
What is so special about those four programs that prevent my recovery from loading?????
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
e2fsck is a filesystem check utility for ext2
mke2fs is for ext2 filesystem creation
parted is a partitioning tool
tune2fs is for change some filesystem parameters (usually checking interval)
I've read that recovery from Amon-Ra creates automatically 3 partitions (ext2, swap and FAT32). So those commands whould probably mean ext2 filesystem creation. I'm sure Amon-Ra could give us more information on this subject because he added them to the image.
Have you checked your SD card?.
PD: I'm waiting for my N21 . So I can't test yet.
andferno said:
e2fsck is a filesystem check utility for ext2
mke2fs is for ext2 filesystem creation
parted is a partitioning tool
tune2fs is for change some filesystem parameters (usually checking interval)
I've read that recovery from Amon-Ra creates automatically 3 partitions (ext2, swap and FAT32). So those commands whould probably mean ext2 filesystem creation. I'm sure Amon-Ra could give us more information on this subject because he added them to the image.
Have you checked your SD card?.
PD: I'm waiting for my N21 . So I can't test yet.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for that insight.
I am not sure what RA's recovery would have done on its own...
but I have initiated and completed successfully a partition of my SDCard that includes FAT32, swap, and ext2.
Now that I have done this, for experimentation really, I don't know how to use it and what it gives me.
Obviously the swap is useless because I would need a cooked Android ROM that would actually utilize swap.
ext2 is probably for apps2sd... which I tried unsuccessfully - probably because of my own mistake.
I will continue trying and report again later.
As far as Amon_RA, he mentioned he was working on upgrading all the recovery images he has put out to the next version - thus we will be in queue until this comes to pass. Maybe we can just skip this version and go to the next
N21 vs DSTL1: stock comparisons
I have completed the comparison of recovery images of the DSTL1 and N21.
For this test I used an original mtd2.img from my DSTL1 and an original mtd2.img from Slemmen's N21.
The recovery images are identical:
Both mt2.img are 4,194,304 bytes
Both mtd2.img-kernel are 2,141,616 bytes
Both mtd2.img-ramdisk.gz are 386,645 bytes
What is also interesting to note is that the two boot images i inspected were also identical.
The DSTL1 boot image is one that came with the 1502 update from General Mobile (which may or may not be identical to the original).
The original N21 boot image, thanks to ikarishinjisan, is identical to the DSTL1 boot image:
Both mt1.img are 4,194,304 bytes
Both mtd1.img-kernel are 2,141,816 bytes
Both mtd1.img-ramdisk.gz are 148,671 bytes
*Notice how both recovery and boot are the same size... must be padded?
*Notice how boot kernel is 200 bytes more than recovery kernel.... interesting...
On a side note:
Bootloader is identical as expected: both ikarishinjisan's and my mtd0.img are 1,048,576 bytes.
If things are going to go custom, it might make some sense to put ext3 filesystems on these things.. ext3 is just ext2 with journalling, which could be helpful since phones can just die/get dropped/lose connection with battery/whatever.
Also, this can be done with the tools already there..
mkfs.ext2
tune2fs -j
dnfm said:
Also, this can be done with the tools already there..
mkfs.ext2
tune2fs -j
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are you referring to the Amon_RA's custom recovery?
I can't get tune2fs onto the recovery without trickery, definitely not noob friendly... until we figure out why.
But great suggestion
I'm guessing the ROM must be coded to make use of ext3, otherwise its worthless?
The kernel would need to be configured to support ext3.
Hi I am currently running debian on my phone using the method outlines here
http://www.myhangoutonline.com/2009/11/22/install-linux-on-your-g1/
Ive gotta say it quite slow and the method of installation is strange.
Here is a video of someone dual booting NATIVE debian on a G1. Read descrip in video for more info.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tX1BOGl8Fnw
I would really want an option where you boot into recovery (Holding Home) and there is a menu where you can choose to boot into a normal recovery (Amon_Ra's) and the other options would let you choose between what OS you want to boot into like Gnome,OpenMoko,Debian. A normal boot would take you back to android.
Speeking of OpenMoko
there is a tut here
http://wiki.openmoko.org/wiki/OpenMoko_on_HTC-Dream
and i was wonderin weather anyone had tried this because it seems very interesting and would make it possible to bood gnome,debian etc
any opinions are highly appreciated
let me know what you think.
i dunno if im allowed to but bump
donut = 1.6 right?
yes
cupcake = 1.5
donut = 1.6
eclair = 2.0/2.1
Hi!
I've got OpenMoko dual-booting natively on my G1.
When I first looked into the problem, I saw that:
1) OpenMoko option involved boot flashing that would disable booting into Android.
2) Debian option had no ready-to-use rootfs. You had to bring on the usbnet and install debian packages through netinstall. But Debian was able to dual boot, thanks to FukTheRegister's excellent recovery image.
I surely needed something in the middle
I had contacted the OpenMoko port developer, leviathan (a nice guy btw). He's doing some great job of hacking the forked Android kernel to work on HTC Dream together with some other guys. He told me that he was continuing his work on OpenMoko for HTC Dream and that made me want to try it instead of Debian. By the way, FukTheRegister's Debian and Ubuntu ports are based on leviathan's OpenMoko kernel.
What I did to install and dual-boot OpenMoko was:
1) I partitioned my microSD card into three partitions: FAT, ext3, ext3
2) I extracted the OpenMoko rootfs to the third partition (ext3)
3) I made myself a recovery image that would consist of the most recent OpenMoko kernel from gitorious AND FukTheRegister's ramdisk (I just glued them together and threw away some modules to make it fit into 5Mb - maximum for recovery partition images)
4) I copied the recent kernel modules to /lib/modules/ on the 3rd partition of the sd card
5) I copied my recovery image to the sd card and flashed it with flash_image recovery /sdcard/openmoko-recovery-partition3.img right on the phone (under root).
After that I was able to boot OpenMoko with holding HOME + END during the bootup or Android (holding nothing).
See http://vaskas.ru/om-g1/ for all the relevant files.
If you want to try it yourself:
- repeat stage 1) after me
- take the openmoko-rootfs-20091128.tar.gz and repeat stage 2) after me
- copy the openmoko-modules-20100128.tar.gz to /lib/modules/ on the 3rd partition and extract it there
- take the openmoko-recovery-partition3.img and repeat stage 5) after me
P.S. I am not 100% sure that it's going to work for you, because I experimented a lot. It's pretty likely to work though.
hi again vaskas!
thx for work. Tried your setup, it worked for me.
Now it would be nice to have a recovery with an option to boot the second ext3.
Openmoko on Dream ----> nice!
Seems to get a usb connection:
http://wiki.openmoko.org/wiki/Usb_networking
Is a ssh/dropbear server already running on boot?
vaskas thx so much for the huge leap forward ecept im a little confused. so when i hold home + power using ur method it will boot into openmoko, butif i boot normally it wouild go into android, but what if i wanted to boot into normal recovery like amon_ra's?
if i boot into android normally and then run quickboot app and select recovery will it boot opoenmoko or amon_ra's recovery. also with your method does keeping apps on the first ext3 still work? while the second ext3 is for openmoko?
also when making second ext3 partition what size should i make it?
p.s this is sooooooo sick with open moko the possibilities are endless aswell as for people who prefer they can turn openmoko into debian and some time in the future android
so future = openmoko installed instead of android and then being able to boot debian/android or stay in openmoko environment.
also if it's not to much trouble vaskas can u please make a vid and put on you tube or here thx in advance andthx for ur hard work
olvap377 said:
vaskas thx so much for the huge leap forward ecept im a little confused. so when i hold home + power using ur method it will boot into openmoko, butif i boot normally it wouild go into android, but what if i wanted to boot into normal recovery like amon_ra's?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, normal recovery won't be there, since my image replaces it. As far as I know, it's the only way to dual-boot now. If you wish to use your normal recovery image (amon_ra's or cyanogen's), just flash it with flash_image recovery my.img. When you're done with it, flash it back to openmoko's.
olvap377 said:
if i boot into android normally and then run quickboot app and select recovery will it boot opoenmoko or amon_ra's recovery. also with your method does keeping apps on the first ext3 still work? while the second ext3 is for openmoko?
also when making second ext3 partition what size should i make it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I haven't tried quickboot yet.
Yes, Apps2SD still works perfectly with the first of ext3 partitions. I suggest that you make the second one at least 700Mb in size. I've got 500Mb taken by OpenMoko, for instance.
olvap377 said:
also if it's not to much trouble vaskas can u please make a vid and put on you tube or here thx in advance andthx for ur hard work
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, you shouldn't really thank me since I only built a recovery image It's the kernel and ramdisk hackers who rock.
I'll make a vid when I have some free time, but I really suggest that you try it yourself
scheich said:
hi again vaskas!
thx for work. Tried your setup, it worked for me.
Now it would be nice to have a recovery with an option to boot the second ext3.
Openmoko on Dream ----> nice!
Seems to get a usb connection:
http://wiki.openmoko.org/wiki/Usb_networking
Is a ssh/dropbear server already running on boot?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
FukTheRegister's ramdisk has such an option. I can try to make such a recovery if you need it.
Yes, dropbear is started automatically.
I'd love to see a solid and stable distro that would provide all the things that Android doesn't have, with:
- A compact desktop environment, supposedly e17 or LXDE
- Midori or Google Chrome
- Pidgin
- Sylpheed or Claws for GPG-secured e-mail
- MPlayer or VLC
- FBReader
- evince
- AbiWord
- Gnumeric
- Conky
- Gpodder for podcasts
- Some music player like Sonata
- Cron, sshd, gcc, scripting languages like Python and Ruby
- Zhone for making calls, texting, storing the address book
See, I'm not advocating touch-oriented software. I think we still need touch-capable apps for calling, texting and the address book. The others can be easily manipulated with the trackball and keyboard on G1.
That's what we should aim for IMHO: http://wiki.openmoko.org/wiki/Image:Debian_lxde_zhone.png
OpenMoko project has all this stuff. And that's really awesome. The question is if such an OS should be based on Angstrom (like OpenMoko SHR) or Debian (see http://wiki.openmoko.org/wiki/Debian). My preference is Debian since I'm a long-time Debian/Ubuntu user.
i prefer debian too and i will try this when i get home
i'm sorry for my really dumb question.
but how can i copy something from windows (7) to a ext2 partition?
and if you are creating those partitions, do both ext2 have to be primary or
one primary and one secondary?
thx in advance
lolmensch said:
i'm sorry for my really dumb question.
but how can i copy something from windows (7) to a ext2 partition?
and if you are creating those partitions, do both ext2 have to be primary or
one primary and one secondary?
thx in advance
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They both have to be primary. I also recommend you to upgrade them to ext3 which is more stable thanks to journaling.
As far as I know, it's not possible to write to extX partitions from Windows. You can copy the files you need to the FAT partition and move them within the phone using Astro or other file manager.
You can mount the second ext3 partition from Terminal Emulator in Android like this:
$ su
# cd /sdcard
# mkdir SD2
# mount /dev/block/mmcblk0p3 /sdcard/SD2
Then it will be accessible from Astro in /sdcard/SD2.
i followed all the steps correctly but it just gets stuch at boot screen if i try to boot into recovery
any advice
maybe this has something to do with the fact that i have ebi1 phone?
pls help i really want this
EDIT:
wow im dumb i figured it out if u look at my sig ull see the way my partitions are setup
i followed all ur steps except each time i changed instructions from p3 to p4 becasue i also have a linux swap so when i installed this recovery it tried to boot from part3 which is my swap and obviously didn;t work
so vaskas can u please for everyone who has a linux swap release another recovery except that boots from part4?
Have also a swap as the fourth partition.. That doesn't matter, I think. Its only important, that the second ext3 is the third partition.
Heres my partition table:
fdisk -l /dev/mmcblk0
Code:
Disk /dev/mmcblk0: 1977 MB, 1977614336 bytes
255 heads, 63 sectors/track, 240 cylinders
Units = cylinders of 16065 * 512 = 8225280 bytes
Disk identifier: 0x000ac1bc
Device Boot Start End Blocks Id System
/dev/mmcblk0p1 1 64 514048+ b W95 FAT32
/dev/mmcblk0p2 65 131 538177+ 83 Linux
/dev/mmcblk0p3 132 223 738990 83 Linux
/dev/mmcblk0p4 224 240 136552+ 82 Linux swap / Solaris
olvap377 said:
i followed all the steps correctly but it just gets stuch at boot screen if i try to boot into recovery
any advice
maybe this has something to do with the fact that i have ebi1 phone?
pls help i really want this
EDIT:
wow im dumb i figured it out if u look at my sig ull see the way my partitions are setup
i followed all ur steps except each time i changed instructions from p3 to p4 becasue i also have a linux swap so when i installed this recovery it tried to boot from part3 which is my swap and obviously didn;t work
so vaskas can u please for everyone who has a linux swap release another recovery except that boots from part4?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok, try http://vaskas.ru/om-g1/openmoko-recovery-partition4.img - it should work.
I'll try to make a multiple-choice one soon.
thx alot il try when i get home from school
EDIT: still dosent work just freezes at boot screen
plzzzz help any advice
olvap377 said:
thx alot il try when i get home from school
EDIT: still dosent work just freezes at boot screen
plzzzz help any advice
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you mean you're stuck into the "G1" screen? If so, it's a recovery/kernel problem, not really connected with partitioning and stuff. I'm not sure if this openmoko kernel supports EBI1/32A, may be it's the problem
Well I have a dream which is 32b but with ebi1 radio I think this is the problem because amon_ra has a special recovery just for rogers dreams meaning something is different between them
If u could compare amon's rogers to normal recovery and find the differences could u chabge yours to make the latest part 4 file ebi1 compatible?
olvap377 said:
Well I have a dream which is 32b but with ebi1 radio I think this is the problem because amon_ra has a special recovery just for rogers dreams meaning something is different between them
If u could compare amon's rogers to normal recovery and find the differences could u chabge yours to make the latest part 4 file ebi1 compatible?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Frankly speaking, I don't think I'm going to have much time for this Since my radio is different, I won't be able to test it properly too.
Actually, I hope that more people join the thread so that we'll be able to solve much more problems together. I wonder where the guys from "Installing Debian on G1" are gone, I saw 2-3 people really interested in native Linux there.
Can you still rename the thread? If so, what do you think about appending something like " - Native OpenMoko and Debian" to it?
EDIT: compared Amon_Ra's recoveries in hex editor, they seem quite different
After some thinking about how I wanted to pursue this project and the recent release of an app that has made this possible, I decided to start working on an app of my own. While I have no experience in making an app, I have already begun working on it. Boot Manager is an awesome app for those that like flashing and running different ROMS frequently, however I have found some things that I do not like about it and features that could be added. My short term goal is to create an app with support for either 2 or 3 Roms and would be free. I'll then release a paid one that will support 5 or more roms and add some other features.
As I said, I have already begun working on it and although it won't utilize the method I wanted to use, I will implement some of it in the future. Right now I have parts of it setup and can already use certain features, but for anyone that has created an app, you know there is a lot of scripting that needs to be done.
Thanks to Conap for the motivation to get my a** back on track.
Partition your sdcard
PARTITION YOUR SDCARD
I have made this really easy to partition your sdcard while preserving all data on the fat32 partition.
You have the option of specifying the size of the ext partitions in /sdcard/dualbootmap.txt
Code:
adb shell
echo 150 200 0 > /sdcard/dualbootmap.txt
The 1st number is cache partition for both rom2 in Mb. For right now I would not do anything less than 125 until I incorporate settings for dalvik-cache on data.
The 2nd number is ROM2 data partition in Mb. Pick whatever size you want.
The 3rd number which isn't used yet will be for a2sd on ROM1. For now this should be kept at 0.
If there is no dualbootmap.txt file the partitions will be automatically set to
cache=150
data=200
a2sd=0
Make sure you have enough free space on the card to accommodate the extra partitions plus an extra 200. If you only have a fat32 partition and use the default values above you would need 550mb of free space. After setting up the roms you will get the extra 200mb back. Its just used as temporary storage.
INSTRUCTIONS:
1. Download sdpart.zip
2. Reboot into recovery
Code:
adb shell reboot recovery
3. Unzip the contents of sdpart.zip and push the files inside sdpart folder to /tmp/
Code:
adb push c:\xxxxxx\sdpart /tmp/
4. run /tmp/sdpart.sh in adb shell
Code:
adb shell /tmp/sdpart.sh
If sdpart.sh doesn't run then you will have to chmod it before running it, but it should already have permission to run.
Code:
adb shell chmod 777 /tmp/sdpart.sh
HELP
Reserved until release day
Can't wait to try it out.
Is it going to support the aria?
12c00000-257fffff : System RAM
THANKS
Sent from my HTC Liberty using XDA App
FFXTDS said:
Can't wait to try it out.
Is it going to support the aria?
12c00000-257fffff : System RAM
Sent from my HTC Liberty using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Updated OP. Thats it for today. I'll post others in the morning
Can I restore a nandroid and then flash the dualboot.zip to make that Rom store to SD instead of wiping everything and flashing the roms?
jblazea50 said:
Can I restore a nandroid and then flash the dualboot.zip to make that Rom store to SD instead of wiping everything and flashing the roms?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You should be able to as long as there is a boot.img in the nandroid which I think there is
I really like this idea. Is there any way that you could modify a recovery to incorporate a bootloader? I believe clockwork is open source and should allow for this to be possible.
I don't know any c programming, but am looking at alternatives. Maybe an app or 1 script that does everything.
Sent from my HERO200 using XDA App
This is F'in epic dude. Thank you!
got this working on my evo,
1. what if i want to flash a new nightly or a update, do i go through the process again? and does it matter if it's on the SD or Phone?
2. how do you nandroid the rom on the SD?
basically should i keep CM6.1 on the Phone or the SD for easy updating
EDIT: i lied it works then when i tried to boot to SD it just sat at the white screen. going to play around with this some tonight
Wow man. This is freaking amazing. I'm definitely going to give this a try. Run CM as my daily rom, but this will help when I am traveling to 4G areas, and I can just flip over to a Sense rom.
Awesome, awesome work.
so if i wanted to put cyanogenmod nightlys on and then update them to a newer nightly version how would i do that without redoing everything?
edit: been messing with this and had my question sitting without hitting submit for like 15 min and apperently in that time someone else asked same question
I can't figure out how to get my base address... Can someone please explain more... I'd love to use this on my incredible
Sent from my Incredible using XDA App
Booting into the rom on the SD doesn't seem to be working. The phone just stays at the initial boot screen. This happens whether I have CM6 or a Sense rom on the SD.
sd card
So how is the speed when running on a class two SD card or a Class 4
Does the rom bog down?
Tried it and when I tried to boot into the rom on sd it got stuck on splash screen. Running miui on phone and had ava 10 on sd.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA App
PikkonX said:
Booting into the rom on the SD doesn't seem to be working. The phone just stays at the initial boot screen. This happens whether I have CM6 or a Sense rom on the SD.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What recovery and phone do you have. Run this from command or terminal and post inside code tags
Code:
adb shell cat /sdcard/dualboot/recovery.log
or attach /sdcard/dualboot/recovery.log so I can look at it. It sounds like I may have the wrong base address. I'm going to sleep now. but will check and update this in the morning
kevinniven said:
So how is the speed when running on a class two SD card or a Class 4
Does the rom bog down?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
im no expert to android, linux, sd cards (lol)... but i think it doesnt matter, once the ROM is loaded it runs off the phone's memory, so the speed shouldnt be affected.
somebody correct me if im wrong
PikkonX said:
Booting into the rom on the SD doesn't seem to be working. The phone just stays at the initial boot screen. This happens whether I have CM6 or a Sense rom on the SD.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yeah i'm getting the same thing wont get past initial bootscreen
Phone = HTC EVO rev 0003
recovery = psfMod 0.7.2 (aka clockwork)
sdcard = 8gb (w/2.2gb free)
and i checked my adress base before hand so i know i got correct one
i will try again tomorrow as i gotta get some sleep now
"...the best choice for a custom ROM on the Captivate" - AndroidCentral
Number One In Random And Plausibly Flawed Battery Testing By Random Persons
6.4
Added 2048 SD Card Script
Added Ram Booster Script
Added Permissions Fix Script
Updated Market
UI Tweaks
SERENDIPITY WEBSITE
A few words about the Optional But Totally Awesome Steam Kernel
Ok, so hopefully you read a bit about it in SzutpY's post. I compiled Steam recovery in English and made a kernel utilizing it. The kernel is similar in many ways to the Universal Lagfix Kernel SztupY also created. It has many of the same lagfix schemes, kernel tweaks, etc, again, all with a touchscreen interface. Other than Steam recovery, this kernel is identical to my 12-23 oc/uv kernel, so it's overclocked, and undervolt configurable, and it should be just as stable as that one.
Do not attempt to take the zImage with Steam recovery and place it in a flashable zip. You'll be a sad panda if you do. I'd advise waiting a few minutes after your system has booted to flash with Neldar's app. If you're using Odin, or Heimdall, reboot to download mode and flash like normal. Those are the options, either Neldar's app (AND NOT Tuxility!!) There are issues with flashing this via redbend_ua - the regular kernel can be flashed via redbend_ua, Steam cannot be.)
Steam recovery is based on ClockworkMod, but you have a touchscreen interface at recovery. Steam has many options to lagfix your system. So, you can have an all ext4 system (including /system), an all jfs system (again, including /system) or something in between. Read through sztupy's posts about Steam, or spend some time playing with it. I have to admit I was a little skeptical of it at first, but after using it for the last week or so, I absolutely love it.
If you're doing a filesystem conversion from Steam recovery, the zeroth thing you should do is check to make sure you have enough room on your SD card to copy /system, /data, /dbdata, and /cache. Then, make a backup. Occasionally after a filesystem conversion, the system will bootloop. Performing a three button forced reset and rebooting solves this. (In my experience at least. Like I said, make sure to backup first.)
If you do choose a No-RFS lagfix in Steam - Make sure you disable it before flashing another kernel/ROM. No-RFS uses a fake /efs to get a completely-rfs free ROM (only works if /system is set to be mounted as rw).
If it seems as though you've lost su (root)
So, I don't know why Steam does this, but the reason people were losing su was because it was automatically mounting /system nosuid. So, to fix this, there's probably more than one way to do this, but an easy way is to go into Steam, under boot options, select 'Always run adb as root' or something like that. Then reboot, open a terminal and type
Code:
mount -o remount,suid /dev/block/stl9 /system
. That will remount su access to /system (pretty important ), and then you will have root again, and Steam is finally usable again. Flash another kernel or whatever) I was really hoping I could blame this on something MikeyMike did, hmm...I may still find a way. ( Alternatively, it seems if you do a filesystem conversion on /system, /system will be remounted suid so you won't have to go through this, and I think /system conversions don't end up in boot loops like /data and /dbdata.
Credits
Xcaliburinhand - without whom we'd all be on JJ4 and JI6. *shudder*
SztupY - Steam recovery is the shiz.
raspdeep, neldar, xan
I'll probably edit this a few more times as there will be things that I want to add but have slipped my mind for the moment.
Ok - I uploaded a copy of the Steam kernel here. It deserves its own thread and it will get one, just don't feel like doing it right now. Read through this post, realize there are some errors with filesystem conversion. Make sure you do backups, if you get into a boot loops, do a hard reset and reboot normally, you should be good. This is meant to be flashed via Neldar's SGS Kernel Flasher app, or something like Heimdall or Odin.
Alright...lets get started
Sent from my liberated Captivate via XDA App.
Just when I think I've finally found a ROM to stick with (Phoenix 1.0) after flashing just about every ROM I see on XDA.......along come some new candy!
yes!!!! definetely gonna donate thanks so much for the hard work mikey!!
Am I the only one that prefers the original clock/alarm that was on the phone? Select custom ringtone is nice and it seems easier than the car/home.
Sent from my SGH-I897 using XDA App
gdbusby said:
Am I the only one that prefers the original clock/alarm that was on the phone? Select custom ringtone is nice and it seems easier than the car/home.
Sent from my SGH-I897 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i love the original too. :/
Weeee!!! Finally!!!! Let see the awesomeness!!!
Running Assonance 5.0 - SpeedMod 256hz K12H - JL2
Mikey, does this contain the jpa wifi fix and external SD mount fix? Thanks.
Sent from my liberated Captivate via XDA App.
This post is no longer relevant. STOP LOOKING AT IT
I have two kernels in this, why do I have to keep hitting F5?
I guess my first post got deleted so I will do another one. This looks like it is going to be good.i actually enjoy the simplistic look.
Sent from my SGH-I897 using XDA App
Download's up.
Trying it out. Thank you.
Sent from my GT-I9000 using XDA App
and I was about to download your other rom.
madjsp said:
and I was about to download your other rom.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was waiting for you to be about to download the other one so I could release this one.
just when i thought i would stop flashing today i see another rom come out.. life of a rom addict
Does this have the AOSP MMS App as well?
How is your Guy's battery life with this
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
BE WARNED - THIS WILL ERASE EVERYTHING ON YOUR PHONE. DO NOT ATTEMPT THIS IF YOU HAVE NOT MADE A BACKUP AND/OR ARE NOT READY TO REINSTALL EVERYTHING ON YOUR PHONE FROM SCRATCH.
Credit goes to bbedward for his initial thread regarding this concept.
STATUS:
2017/01/08 - Not liking the performance of my Galaxy S3, so I've ordered a new phone (Huawei P8 Lite) for $58 from eBay! Supposedly brand new. I figured I'd have to give it a try just to see. Once I set this phone up I'll start tinkering with my Nexus 6 again. Phone should arrive around 17 Jan!
FOCUS:
Getting F2FS on ANY ROM, but for my purposes, I'm focused on getting F2FS with Flash Kernel to work on Nitrogen OS (if this can be done, then it can be done with any ROM!)
BASICS:
- Need recovery & kernel that support f2fs (tools + kernel driver version must match or be compatible - not sure what the specifics are yet)
Latest New Info:
- The Flash has said that his kernel and crDroid work with F2FS (I haven't tested it myself yet - this version of crDroid actually specifies F2FS support)
2017/01/08
- Found this thread by NABENDU1. It's for Nexus 4, but it gives some good insight on how F2FS works.
- @vprasad1 found another working combination (post #15) - franco.Kernel - r60 Anykernel 7.1.1 with Danvdh's Stock Lite N6F26Q 7.1.1
Explaining a few details:
The issue here is that the exact version of F2FS tools included in most modded recoveries isn't actually specified (that I have found) and the version of tools that end up in the ROM (/system/bin/), which come from the recovery unless built into the ROM, must be compatible. One of the following is true (not sure which one yet):
- the F2FS tools version must be the same or greater than the kernel driver support version
- the F2FS tools version must be the same or less than the kernel driver support version
- the F2FS tools version must match the kernel driver support version
Given that The Flash is consistently including the latest F2FS support in his kernel, and since I've had the most trouble getting F2FS support to work with his kernel and other ROMs that technically don't support F2FS (using bbedward's method mentioned above - link to thread included) I'm inclined to think that the F2FS tools must be the same or greater version compared to the kernel driver support, though I have no way of confirming this yet. Hopefully I'll have different luck with Flash Kernel v1.7!
========
I used:
- Nexus Root Toolkit v2.1.9
- Nitrogen OS 2016-11-19
- MagiKernel v1.1 Stable-1023
- TWRP 3.0.2-0 (modded by xanaxdroid - thread is here)
(TWRP v3.0.2-0 by xanaxdroid mirror) - the original link is down.
I'll take these down if xanaxdroid asks. I have yet to hear from him...
Steps for clean install (and initial install of F2FS recovery / conversion to F2FS):
1) revert to stock (Nexus Root Toolkit)
2) flash recovery with f2fs support (Nexus Root Toolkit)
3) boot into recovery on device
4) full wipe device (normal wipe)
5) convert /cache & /data to f2fs
6) copy over desired kernel and rom to /sdcard
7) install rom & then kernel
8) run adb commands:
# adb shell
# mount -o rw /system
# cp /sbin/fsck.f2fs /system/bin/
# cp /sbin/mkfs.f2fs /system/bin/
# chmod a+x /system/bin/*f2fs*
9) reboot
========
When changing ROMs/kernel (F2FS recovery already installed):
1) boot into recovery
2) do full wipe (f2fs should have stayed from the first time)
3) install rom & then kernel
4) run adb commands:
# adb shell
# mount -o rw /system
# cp /sbin/fsck.f2fs /system/bin/
# cp /sbin/mkfs.f2fs /system/bin/
# chmod a+x /system/bin/*f2fs*
5) reboot
========
More semi-lengthy explanation about fstab:
bbedward suggests a difference in the fstab as being the primary suspect causing the difference in compatibility. Here's the only difference I could find that seemed to be relevant:
- the fstab that worked (MagiKernel + TWRP v3.0.2-0 (by xanaxdroid) + Nitro OS)
/devices/*/xhci-hcd.0.auto/usb* auto auto defaults voldmanaged=usb:auto
- the fstab that didn't work (Flash Kernel + TWRP v3.0.2-0 (by xanaxdroid) + Nitro OS)
*block/sda* auto auto defaults voldmanaged=usbdisk:auto,noemulatedsd
Both fstab files did clearly have the lines needed to mount /data and /cache as f2fs, but they were identical.
NOTE: I also tried TWRP v3.0.0-0 (by xanaxdroid) with Flash Kernel and still no dice. I'm a fan of Flash Kernel since it's my first custom kernel I've played with. I hope to be able to use it some day with Nitrogen OS! Until then, thanks MagiKernel! (maybe I'll convert??? ) <- MagiKernel development has halted for now
========
What I've tried before:
All of the following implies that I've used the previously mentioned adb commands to copy over the f2fs tools and set the proper permissions.
In my experience, it seems that f2fs requires just the right combination of kernel + recovery. For example I used Nitrogen OS (2016-11-19) + Flash Kernel + mod TWRP 3.0.2-0 and it hasn't worked for me, but Nitrogen OS + MagiKernel + mod TWRP v3.0.2-0 did work. The failure for f2fs to work with Nitro OS + Flash Kernel is very reproducible, as is the success with Nitro OS + MagiKernel. (Again using TWRP v3.0.2-0 modded by xanaxdroid).
Keep in mind that the developer of Flash Kernel (developed by The Flash) has tested his kernel with crDroid (a CyanogenMod base ROM) and it worked for him, but I don't know what version of modded TWRP he was using and what version of f2fs tools were in that recovery. From what I've noticed, there seems to be a fundamental difference with CyanogenMod based ROMs when it comes to f2fs support, either that or there's just a version mismatch of f2fs tools between certain recovery + kernel combos. I don't know enough to understand the difference yet, but it is clear that just because a kernel claims to support f2fs doesn't mean that it will work with any ROM, even if you follow bbedward's tutorial mentioned at the top of this post.
The kernel and the recovery must work together (as in what version of mkfs.f2fs / fsck.f2fs supported by kernel & recovery must match (i think - thanks to bbedward again for this info)). The main issue here is that most modded recovery zips/imgs (that I have found) don't list the version of f2fs tools they have. On the other hand usually you can see this info on the main page of any given kernel developer.
I haven't found any specific rhyme or reason yet, but for those looking for Nitrogen OS (2016-11-19 - Android 7.1 - Nougat) + f2fs, this will help you.
NOTE: I'm a clean-freak, so I enjoy clean flashes, so my instructions are geared toward clean flashes, not dirty flashes. Having said that, doing this with a dirty flash is possible, but it will depend on the ROM/kernel you choose as to the details in how you upgrade/switch the ROM/kernel. Done properly, you should only have to switch file systems once and forego any future wiping of your /sdcard or internal storage.
========
NOTE : You'll know your recovery + kernel combo isn't working right when it takes longer than usual to get off the bootloader screen and start with your ROM's animation boot screen. If it's taking too long, you're probably having everything converted back to ext4.
*** WARNING *** WARNING *** WARNING *** WARNING ***
DO NOT INTERRUPT THIS PROCESS DURING BOOT. If you do then you'll render your /data partition inaccessible. It's still fixable with Nexus Root Toolkit > revert to stock, but that's a pain and it takes a while.
This OP will be updated as new info is uncovered!
Thank you for the updated tutorial and information! Been reading up on the benefits and side effects of f2fs. But wasn't sure on whether to do it. Like you I am on nitrogen ROM, 12.4.26. and am a fan of flash kernel. Il will definitely look into this. Also I notice that the link you posted for magikernel isn't working. Either way huge thank you.
Edit - Just read the original thread. Want to thank you again for hoe you asked for his approval first before making a new thread. Very respectful. Not to say people don't respect devs or users in general. Just wanted to add I appreciate you taking the time to reach out him first prior to making this thread.
Thank you again.
Sent from my Nexus 6 using XDA-Developers mobile app
ozzmanj1 said:
Thank you for the updated tutorial and information! Been reading up on the benefits and side effects of f2fs. But wasn't sure on whether to do it. Like you I am on nitrogen ROM, 12.4.26. and am a fan of flash kernel. Il will definitely look into this. Also I notice that the link you posted for magikernel isn't working. Either way huge thank you.
Edit - Just read the original thread. Want to thank you again for hoe you asked for his approval first before making a new thread. Very respectful. Not to say people don't respect devs or users in general. Just wanted to add I appreciate you taking the time to reach out him first prior to making this thread.
Thank you again.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the feedback!
I'm still researching a way to get Flash Kernel with Nitro OS + f2fs. I have some ideas. I'll update the first post with any new findings.
Edit: unfortunately MagiKernel is dead. So ill be hot on another trail soon. Also MagiKernel isnt as good as Flash out-of-the-box in my experience so far.
ozzmanj1 said:
Also I notice that the link you posted for magikernel isn't working. Either way huge thank you.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I actually just tested the link to MagiKernel on my PC and my phone (on XDA Labs) and it worked fine. Are you using another (older) version of XDA forum viewer?
EDIT: OP updated. The "issues" we all run into is a version mismatch between RECOVERY & KERNEL mostly. As long as RECOVERY & KERNEL f2fs tools match, then you can copy over (mkfs.f2fs & fsck.f2fs) from /sbin/ to /system/bin/ and get any ROM to be compatible with F2FS.
EDIT: modified links and removed "" in URL tags. The quotes were necessary for proper display in the XDA Labs app, but not compatible with XDA Legacy app. I've switched to use XDA legacy!
Will this fix low battery throttling and video recording
PunishedSnake said:
Will this fix low battery throttling and video recording
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
LOL, no.
This won't "fix".... ANYTHING.
In fact, this will very likely BREAK things.
Lol how so
No not breaking things here ... Not any more than usual tinkering under the hood... I'm just trying to flush out bbedward's old thread with some more info...
PunishedSnake said:
Will this fix low battery throttling and video recording
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
To give you an answer, no it won't. This info will only "possibly" help you get a ROM to run on f2fs that was not initially designed to do so.
@ozzmanj1
Well the Nitrogen OS ROM developer just let me know he has no plan to include F2FS tools. Looks like we gotta go with plan B...
TheArkive said:
@ozzmanj1
Well the Nitrogen OS ROM developer just let me know he has no plan to include F2FS tools. Looks like we gotta go with plan B...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is a darn shame. Looking at the comparisons of Ext4 and F2FS and it makes me wonder why it has gone more popular. I appreciate your time and work looking into this. Sadly with my schedule I do not have to do a lot of digging with wife, and kids and works....blah blah....lol. Anyways, thank you for letting me know about Nitro.
Side note, any suggestions on another ROM that you are aware of that supports F2FS?
ozzmanj1 said:
That is a darn shame. Looking at the comparisons of Ext4 and F2FS and it makes me wonder why it has gone more popular. I appreciate your time and work looking into this. Sadly with my schedule I do not have to do a lot of digging with wife, and kids and works....blah blah....lol. Anyways, thank you for letting me know about Nitro.
Side note, any suggestions on another ROM that you are aware of that supports F2FS?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Flash said that latest crDroid worked fine. I haven't been able to confirm yet. I have a new smartphone on the way to setup as my primary phone while I experiment on my Nexus 6. Won't get here until Jan 23rd
TheArkive said:
The Flash said that latest crDroid worked fine. I haven't been able to confirm yet. I have a new smartphone on the way to setup as my primary phone while I experiment on my Nexus 6. Won't get here until Jan 23rd
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just came across this new kernel that has f2fs support. Based on flash kernel and afew other kernels.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=3526034
Going to look into it as flash kernel may drop nexus 6 support soon due to school obligations
Sent from my Nexus 6 using XDA-Developers mobile app
ozzmanj1 said:
Just came across this new kernel that has f2fs support. Based on flash kernel and afew other kernels.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=3526034
Going to look into it as flash kernel may drop nexus 6 support soon due to school obligations
Sent from my Nexus 6 using XDA-Developers mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the news! I'll be checking that out as well.
FYI this works using franco.Kernel - r60 Anykernel 7.1.1 with Danvdh's Stock Lite N6F26Q 7.1.1
Code:
mount | grep f2fs
/dev/block/platform/msm_sdcc.1/by-name/userdata on /data type f2fs (rw,seclabel,nosuid,nodev,noatime,nodiratime,background_gc=on,user_xattr,inline_xattr,acl,inline_data,inline_dentry,flush_merge,extent_cache,mode=adaptive,active_logs=6)
/dev/block/platform/msm_sdcc.1/by-name/cache on /cache type f2fs (rw,seclabel,nosuid,nodev,noatime,nodiratime,background_gc=on,user_xattr,inline_xattr,acl,inline_data,inline_dentry,flush_merge,extent_cache,mode=adaptive,active_logs=6)
I tried Aero 1.0 Linaro kernel with Danvdh's Stock Lite N6F26Q 7.1.1 but it kept forcing /cache and /data to return to ext4.
Could also be that the rom is coded not to allow it as it is not really stable enough. Main reason it is not implemented in Android.
zelendel said:
Could also be that the rom is coded not to allow it as it is not really stable enough. Main reason it is not implemented in Android.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Was that in response to my post???
Sent from my SM-N910T using Tapatalk
vprasad1 said:
FYI this works using franco.Kernel - r60 Anykernel 7.1.1 with Danvdh's Stock Lite N6F26Q 7.1.1
I tried Aero 1.0 Linaro kernel with Danvdh's Stock Lite N6F26Q 7.1.1 but it kept forcing /cache and /data to return to ext4.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Many thanks for the info! I'm definitely trying to find combinations that in fact do work, and hopefully derive a method for getting it to work on other combinations as well (hopefully).
Thanks again for the help!
TheArkive said:
Many thanks for the info! I'm definitely trying to find combinations that in fact do work, and hopefully derive a method for getting it to work on other combinations as well (hopefully).
Thanks again for the help!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just a quick link I came across. Not sure if it's useful but as it pertains to f2fs I thought I'd share.
https://www.xda-developers.com/xda-...upersu-has-trouble-with-f2fs-data-partitions/
Sent from my Nexus 6 using XDA-Developers Legacy app
What is F2FS
Can Ya Here Me Now