Database Users

What's the verdict on screen protectors?

Do you use them on your tablet?

I do.
Sent from my HTC Incredible S using XDA

tandfeen said:
I do.
Sent from my HTC Incredible S using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same here, the screen is too valuable on the tab to get scratched imo ...

I've ordered this one for my SGS
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B003VWR2GO/ref=oh_o00_s00_i00_details
The review I've read was saying it was pretty good, barely noticable, wich is a must considering a big plus on samsung's products are the screen.
I'll see if it's worthy, if it is, I'll order this one for the tab:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0...TJV_2?ie=UTF8&m=A1E9T6XPH2ITJV&n=&s=&v=glance
(anyone has it already?)

I had one on originally, but got the newton rings and sent it back. I never bothered putting one on my new tab. I actually much prefer the feel of it without the screen protector. I have a case that covers the screen when I'm not using it, so I feel the risk of scratching is minimal. The protector just felt sort of rubbery, while the bare glass feels really smooth and slick. Could be the brand of screen protector. But I don't see much of a benefit of putting one on at this point.
But I do have 4 kids, so maybe you don't want take my advice on using supplemental protection...

Yep, don't feel right unless i do. I use a zagg from best buy, since they have never died on me.

Nope, I just use the official Samsung "book cover" case. Why would I want to cover such a sexy, smooth glass screen with a piece of plastic?

I did, and took it off weeks after. No matter what protector you use, it will diminish the quality of the screen. I tried the Zagg and BodyGuardz and when I took them off again, I realized that the screen is too sexy to be hindered. It's Gorilla Glass people; it doesn't scratch that easily. I have my tablet with a TPU case and I have no scratches so far. Just be careful where you put it and you're good to go.

I'm a huge fan of Matte finish anti-glare screen protectors. My tab is sporting one, so is my Galaxy S2...other protectors just get covered in fingerprints as well as not having one on... you should try it. Some people like them some don't... IMO best type of screen protectors.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I777 using xda premium

I've had mine since they first day that Samsung sold the Tab and have never used a screen protector. Not a single scratch or mark on the screen.
Tablets are different than phones. Generally people chose a case that closes over the screen. It's not like you're going to put it in your pocket and get the screen scratched by your keys.
If your case doesn't close to cover the screen or you don't use a case all the time then it might be recommended to use a screen protector. Otherwise the only thing that should come in contact with the screen is your finger or a stylus. Unless, of course, you drop it.

I have had mine since launch with no screen protector and no scratches. It might be a question you have to ask yourself, as far as how much wear and tear will your tab see? It's not like a phone I keep in my pocket and carry everywhere (although I do take my tablet just about everywhere) that can get scratched by keys and the like.

+1 on matte protectors. Also, get a full body protector (sides and back are not scratch resistant!)

I, personally, can't stand the matte ones. It makes the screen look too grainy
Sent from my ADR6425LVW using XDA

+ 1
I use a bookcase and screen protector. I usually take care of my electronics but somehow I managed to get some small scratches on my screen. I am not sure if they came from using my dagi stylus or from the cloth I use to wipe it with (dry booger perhaps). If you plan on using a stylus I would go for a screen protector. I am currently using one from Belkin but wouldn't really recommend it. I applied as pr instruction but it has an oily look to it. I spoke to their customer service and they said they would send me a new one but haven't received it yet (2 weeks).

SkizzMcNizz said:
I, personally, can't stand the matte ones. It makes the screen look too grainy
Sent from my ADR6425LVW using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I love matte ones but again the rainbow effect annoys me, so I found this SGP Ultra Fine - they advertise it as NO RAINBOW effects (link)
Does anyone here uses this and know it to be true or know if any other screen protectors do this?
I'm quite annoyed at the fact that the screen isn't oleophobic, attracts too many fingerprints !
Cheers

Never used them on SGS or Tab. Screens still look as good as new.
Gesendet von meinem GT-I9000

Nope... I have the Samsung case which protects the tablet well and as others have said it's Gorilla glass, so it doesn't scratch easily. The screen is too nice to cover it up.
I also don't have one on my sgs2 which is always in my pocket (nothing else in the same pocket) and it doesn't have any scratches after about 7 months.
I really question the use of cases and screen protectors for phones... In 2-3 years you are likely gonna change phones anyway... Why rob yourself of the smoother and better looking screen? So that it's still in good shape when you get rid of it? ? ? I'd rather enjoy the phone to it's full potential while I use it with the risk of getting scratches than keeping it in pristine shape for when it ends up in a drawer or in someone else's hands.

fnair said:
Nope... I have the Samsung case which protects the tablet well and as others have said it's Gorilla glass, so it doesn't scratch easily. The screen is too nice to cover it up.
I also don't have one on my sgs2 which is always in my pocket (nothing else in the same pocket) and it doesn't have any scratches after about 7 months.
I really question the use of cases and screen protectors for phones... In 2-3 years you are likely gonna change phones anyway... Why rob yourself of the smoother and better looking screen? So that it's still in good shape when you get rid of it? ? ? I'd rather enjoy the phone to it's full potential while I use it with there risk of getting scratches than keeping it in pristine shape for when it ends up in a drawer or in someone else's hands.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Many times 2-3 years is a longer time than I think is actual. More like 1-2.
But on point, because a device without scratches on on the screen can bring twice as much used than one with scratches.
Just my two cents.
Sent from my GT-P7510 using XDA Premium HD app

Phantom Skinz....

The shop that i bought my tab from didnt recommed it.
Sent from my GT-P7510 using xda premium

Should I use the G4 without screen protector?

I really hate to use these things and honestly im really careful when it comes to my phone, I used to have the the epic 4g touch without screen protector since day 1 and all it got was a tiny scratch which I dont even know how it happened.
So what are your opinions regarding this issue, should I just use it without screen protector?
Sent from my SPH-L720 using Tapatalk 4 Beta

Case or no case?
Sent from my SPH-L720 using Tapatalk 4 Beta

screen protector no. case yes. that's how I roll. :thumbup:

Depends on how mad it will make you if you get a small scratch...
Personally I hate screen protectors, and won't use them. Same for cases. But I also typically only keep phones for 6 months, so not a lot of time to mess them up too badly.
On this phone, though, I did get the s-view flip case. Overpriced, but has a certain cool factor I like.
Sent from my SPH-L720 using Tapatalk 2

EPayne123 said:
Case or no case?
Sent from my SPH-L720 using Tapatalk 4 Beta
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes Im rocking the neo hybrid case as of now
Sent from my SPH-L720 using Tapatalk 4 Beta

I never had a screen protector on the E4GT or my GS3, NEVER had a scratch on either of them and I put my phone in my pocket with my keys. Never had a case either and the GS3 never even cracked after 50 drops from my lap. Gorilla glass lives up to its name.

Thank you everyone that replied, I removed this piece of "..." lol I hated it way to much
Sent from my SPH-L720 using Tapatalk 4 Beta

Rasmux said:
Thank you everyone that replied, I removed this piece of "..." lol I hated it way to much
Sent from my SPH-L720 using Tapatalk 4 Beta
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I actually have a Zagg HD shield on mine plus a TPU case. I went without one for a week and the amount of smudges and fingerprints on the screen drove me nuts. I was constantly wiping it on my pants leg or using my eyeglass cloth to clean it. That's when I went to BB and had them install one and I couldn't be happier. It doesn't take away anything from the phone, adds a level of protection( even if minute) and I've literally thrown this thing across the room trying to catch it from falling one time. It fell face down and I was afraid to even look at it in fear that it smashed on my hardwood floor. I turned it over and not a single scratch.
What exactly did you hate about it? Which shield did you have?

I use the Zagg HD shield as well and I love it. It cleans off easily and lets the screen shine through just fine.

gershee said:
screen protector no. case yes. that's how I roll. :thumbup:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
^^ Same. Had an XtremeGuard on it which I ordered for about 79 cents before getting the phone so would have something when I got the device. However, it was way too sticky so ripped it off and doubt will be putting another one on. When I don't even use the phone for a year before upgrading it makes sense for me to get the full experience (way the screen is supposed to feel). However, if I wanted to spend the money would probably make an exception for one of the glass protectors.
In conclusion I would say it depends on the environment you are in, whether using a case and which type, how well you take care of things, if anyone else uses the device, and how long you are going to have it for.

Rasmux said:
Yes Im rocking the neo hybrid case as of now
Sent from my SPH-L720 using Tapatalk 4 Beta
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am currently using the Neo Hybrid case with the Spigen glass.t slim screen protector.
After having the case and screen protector on for over a month I love the case but could do without the glass.t
If it wasn't so expensive I would prob take it off.
My case and glass.t came with a free Spigen Ultra Crystal screen protector which I put on my wife's S4 and I actually like it better than the glass.t
Honestly with the S4 having Gorilla Glass 3 I'm not sure how much of a necessity the screen protector is but if you're like me and you don't wanna risk a scratch I would prob go for the Spigen Ultra Crystal if I could do it over.

2OG Epics, Epic4GT and now the S4, never had a screen protector, never had any scratches.

I've become very protective with my phone investments. I have yet to drop my S4 within the month of ownership. Knock on wood... I like originality. I can't stand cases and screen protectors which is why I don't use them and instead grab protection just-in-case. Some cases are more prone to actually damage your device. I say that from experience. Had 8 EVO 3D's of which 2 were dropped with cases and shattered my screen. The rest were just refurbished defects but that's another story. =P I say no to any extras unless you feel the need for a case and/or any other method of protection. Maybe start a new trend and use a non-lubricated condom. Could work. Hahaha.
Sent from my SPH-L720 using xda app-developers app

The Zaggs, and Ghost armors are ok for a few months, and then they start getting their own scratches and distortions... The protectors, ironically, scratch easier than the gorilla glass does. They do, however, give you a little extra shatter protection. I gave up on invisishield and decided to just be careful. I like it better without the shield. I DO use a cover though. It gives you an added lip around the screen to prevent ground contact on the screen.

Landon4444 said:
I am currently using the Neo Hybrid case with the Spigen glass.t slim screen protector.
After having the case and screen protector on for over a month I love the case but could do without the glass.t
If it wasn't so expensive I would prob take it off.
My case and glass.t came with a free Spigen Ultra Crystal screen protector which I put on my wife's S4 and I actually like it better than the glass.t
Honestly with the S4 having Gorilla Glass 3 I'm not sure how much of a necessity the screen protector is but if you're like me and you don't wanna risk a scratch I would prob go for the Spigen Ultra Crystal if I could do it over.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think I might try the one that came with the case since it was free and I got nothing to lose, bad case scenario ill just remove it lol
Sent from my SPH-L720 using Tapatalk 4 Beta

I rock the zagg front and back protector and love it im thinking of twking it off the back though so I can get the real feel of the back at least
Sent from my SPH-L720 using xda app-developers app

I would rather live with a scratch than live with a screen protector. The glass on my s3 never scratched but I'm also pretty careful with my electronics. Its like when you see an old lady with a huge dashmat that looks like crap and she will never even see the nice dash hiding under it.
Sent from my SPH-L720 using xda app-developers app

Use a screen protector, I scratched my screen in my pocket.
Sent from my SPH-L720 using Tapatalk 2

Would you buy a Benz and leave the door unlocked?
There's no logical justification to have this fantastic, super expensive phone and not have adequate protection.
Sent from my SPH-L720 using xda app-developers app

I use screen protectors on every phone I had and cases. I don't like have scratches or anything like that on my phone or screen.
Sent from my SPH-L720 using Tapatalk 4 Beta

S4 gets easily scratched

Hi, I was wondering if any of you S4 users have any scratches on your screen? I have quite a lot and have had the phone for a month. I thought gorilla glass 3 would be tougher than GG2. My HTC One had less scratches and I had it for longer. My brother had the S4 and complained about the amount of scratches also.

I have also noticed a couple of scratches on the screen. I have had mine for just over a month.

lot of it is down to environment. No amount of careful use will help if there is lint / dust particles in your pocket. Those are invisible but those minute sand particles will scratch anything short of diamond.
My sis has lot of fine hairline scratches on the ONE's soft key area which is only thing exposed. Screen part was covered and as some screen protectors had issues with soft keys, she had cut bottom part of the screen protector and it has fine scratches there.
Unless you really make sure there is no lint or you live in area which does not have too much wind dust, it is not easy to keep the phone scratchless without screen protector and without babying it.
I have always said, put a screen protector on it. Nature is more unpredictable than our technology, and more harsh than what we think.

I have absolutely no scratches and I wouldn't exactly say I baby my phone either
Sent from my SPH-L720 using xda app-developers app

I just would hate to see my s4 get scratches and i hate the usual screen protectors so I got spigen glass screen protector. It's the best and I would absolutely recommend it. It's a small cost to pay in my opinion.

vampyren said:
I just would hate to see my s4 get scratches and i hate the usual screen protectors so I got spigen glass screen protector. It's the best and I would absolutely recommend it. It's a small cost to pay in my opinion.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+100000 i love mine ! :good:

I have not a single scratch on my screen and i have had my phone a month ;P

I learned my lesson when my S2 had so much scratches without using screen protector. Now, I am using screen protector to protect the screen of my S4. It's cheap though.
Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk 2

pauldexter said:
I learned my lesson when my S2 had so much scratches without using screen protector. Now, I am using screen protector to protect the screen of my S4. It's cheap though.
Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Really? I had my S2 for a year and a half and didn't have any noticeable scratches. Just some minor ones if I looked too closely. And I never ever used a screen protector or a case. S2 was a tank.

Moz007 said:
+100000 i love mine ! :good:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same here. It's pricey but it's the best. I love it.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using xda app-developers app

about 3 months and screen stay the same, no any damned even a minor scratch

Had mine since week 1 in the UK... Not 1 mark on my screen, at all.
Sent from my GT-I9505 using xda app-developers app

I had my S2 for 2 years without it getting scratched at all. My S4 has an inch long scratch in the middle of the screen after 3 months.. No idea how it happened.

Ask your self the question, do you use the S4 over 10 years (or longer) ? i don't and i don't care either if it is getting scratched or if the glass breaks.

paulfinch said:
Really? I had my S2 for a year and a half and didn't have any noticeable scratches. Just some minor ones if I looked too closely. And I never ever used a screen protector or a case. S2 was a tank.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It probably depends on the phone usage. For example when I am listening to music, I usually put my device down (the speaker is facing front).
Sent from my GT-I9505 using Tapatalk 2

Should I use a the Edge without a screen protector?

I really have troubles finding a good screen protector for the device since Im not living in 1st world countries. Chinese ones have the curved parts peeled off after 1 or 2 days.
I'm ordering armorsuit films on Amazon and it takes a month to deliver, should I put away the device and wait for the protectors delivery before using it?

Yes imo use one keeps resell value high
Send From My Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge Via - XDA HD Premium

No.
Drive it like you stole it.

I kind of gave up on searching for screen protectors too. I now use the phone without a screen protector, with just a back case (the official plastic one).

nobnut said:
No.
Drive it like you stole it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Indeed this is the way I'm rolling at the mo

I like it raw.

jayr04 said:
I like it raw.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ODB!

marcgear said:
Indeed this is the way I'm rolling at the mo
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
jayr04 said:
I like it raw.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Been using it for 3 days without protection, then I got the spigen crystal and it's awful. Fingerprint magnet. Like a condom I want to take off. I just might too
Sent from my Blackberry Bold

Brava27 said:
Been using it for 3 days without protection, then I got the spigen crystal and it's awful. Fingerprint magnet. Like a condom I want to take off. I just might too
Sent from my Blackberry Bold
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I go the spigen one too, and it doesn't stick to the edges at all. However I did get an email from them that they will be sending me another one as they are aware of the problem.

Zer0_ said:
I go the spigen one too, and it doesn't stick to the edges at all. However I did get an email from them that they will be sending me another one as they are aware of the problem.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had very bad experience with magnetic films (like Spigen one) on curved screens (s6 edge), the sides dont stick at all. The Armorsuit protectors work better since it is sillicon-like films (soft) with an abrasive layer to make sure it sticks, it has self healing to.

3mk arc 3d try.
Wysłane z mojego SM-G935F przy użyciu Tapatalka

nudawa said:
I had very bad experience with magnetic films (like Spigen one) on curved screens (s6 edge), the sides dont stick at all. The Armorsuit protectors work better since it is sillicon-like films (soft) with an abrasive layer to make sure it sticks, it has self healing to.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Awesome, I'll look into it.
How does the self healing mechanism work?

It heals minor scatches, go to their website for more info armorsuit.com

Not a fan of screen protectors on curved screens. Had a 920 back in the day (granted screen protector tech has come a long way) but i tried for a few weeks and then took it off.
Dont use them on any phone now, really all it does is stop scratches (which dont happen frequently with new gorilla glass).
If you want drop protection get a good case.

My s6 edge has some scratches after 3 days, though they're not deep but still leave minor distortions on screen which annoys me very much

I ordered the Ultimate shields and they work fine for me. Dificult to install tho
Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

Been going case free since my Note 3 and protector free since my note 4. My Note 4 did get a scratch on the screen but I just couldn't stand the tempered glass protectors' terrible fit on the Note 4 and 5 and the soft protectors felt like crap when using the stylus... I'm not fond of the glare so I've got a Matte Skinomi screen protector on the way for the screen and one of their front and back film kits to just apply to the back side (it wasn't available in matte, hence the two orders)... We'll see. If I do end up getting a case it'll only be on the phone when I'm working in the garage or doing working on finishing my basement.

nudawa said:
I had very bad experience with magnetic films (like Spigen one) on curved screens (s6 edge), the sides dont stick at all. The Armorsuit protectors work better since it is sillicon-like films (soft) with an abrasive layer to make sure it sticks, it has self healing to.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
All these wet-apply protectors like Armorsuit are just awful; hideous orange-peel look, awful touch response, miserable experience...
in my opinion

I have been using gadgetshieldz protectors for a while now. Very good protection in my opinion. Protects the curved edges both on the front as well as back. Ordered one for my edge 7 and mine is on the way now. I have been using their textured skins too on my OP2 and they are fantastic. Exactly the same as the Dbrand ones.

Have a skinomi front and back protector with a symmetry case. Applied perfect but the case is now picking the corner up ruining the protector. I think I'm going to just rock it without a protector

Screen protector suggestions

Can someone please suggest a screen protector that doesn't have a rubbery feel to it?

The original factory one was good.
Probably as good as it gets.
I'm using Gorilla IQ Sheild. Feels ok but a little of that feel you don't want especially with the spen.
The urethane though is self healing (indentations) and provides good wear resistance.
Wet applied ones are also the easiest to properly install with a low install failure rate.

blackhawk said:
The original factory one was good.
Probably as good as it gets.
I'm using Gorilla IQ Sheild. Feels ok but a little of that feel you don't want especially with the spen.
The urethane though is self healing (indentations) and provides good wear resistance.
Wet applied ones are also the easiest to properly install with a low install failure rate.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, I don't like that mushy feeling when using the S-Pen.
Sent from my SM-N975U using Tapatalk

lennie paz said:
Yeah, I don't like that mushy feeling when using the S-Pen.
Sent from my SM-N975U using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah I noticed that too. The glass protectors are harder to install and a lot of cursing if the case dislodges them.
I don't use the spen much for drawing. It's a tradeoff you need to weigh.
These phones absolutely need a case and screen protector or they will get marred* and damaged.
*As a scientific experiment, lol, I took off the screen protector of my S4+ as it had a partially blown display driver anyway to see how it would fare. Felt a lot better but... even with care I had scratches on the glass after about 4 months.
The 10+'s Gorilla glass isn't much more scratch resistant...

blackhawk said:
Yeah I noticed that too. The glass protectors are harder to install and a lot of cursing if the case dislodges them.
I don't use the spen much for drawing. It's a tradeoff you need to weigh.
These phones absolutely need a case and screen protector or they will get marred* and damaged.
*As a scientific experiment, lol, I took off the screen protector of my S4+ as it had a partially blown display driver anyway to see how it would fare. Felt a lot better but... even with care I had scratches on the glass after about 4 months.
The 10+'s Gorilla glass isn't much more scratch resistant...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I wish I could find an aftermarket one, that acted exactly like the factory one.
Sent from my SM-N975U using Tapatalk

lennie paz said:
Yeah, I don't like that mushy feeling when using the S-Pen.
Sent from my SM-N975U using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I hear you.
Not providing one is a major Samsung fail.
However it be almost impossible to apply; the self adhesive ones can be real bears to put on.
The factory one has almost zero edge gap.
Like the ones I'm using as they are only $5 a pop and last a long time. They feel isn't a major issue for me.
Can't have everything... my would case likely dislodge a glass one... and I like my Bolt case a lot.